What makes a social issue even graver than it already is? When nobody knows it exists. Were I to make even the barest of a mention of abortion, gun control, or climate change to my friends, I would have a full fledged debate on my hands, but when I mentions the issues withing the DCF and the foster system, all I receive is questioning looks and the sound of crickets. How can change be effected when nobody is aware of the problem? The answer is that it can't. Luckily, some of the adults in my life have personal connections to the system and were able to give truly insightful testimonies. The overall view of this complex beast is that well, its dying. It simply is not effective enough, with ever increasing numbers of children in crisis and a fall in the number of foster families, things are not going well. The interview I will focus on today came to me completely by accident. We had a substitute named **** in AP Biology, and well...she was a talker. I was focused on my work, but I kept hearing buzz words like child, family issues, stress, and foster family. As it turned out, for the last 40 years, she had worked in the "planning room," working with troubled students. As I began to talk to her I realized she had the most amazing stories, having gone through the foster system, she had stories of her own but more importantly, stories of students today. Perhaps one of her most heartbreaking stories began with a child who every day would refuse to do his work, get sent to the planning room, and promptly fall asleep on the couch provided. This happened every day, until on the day of February break, the principle came to **** and said, you need to stop this, you can't let this kid camp out in your room, So she went to the student and said "after February break, you have to stop sleeping in my room." }"It's February break?" the child said, " Mrs. ****, what am I going to eat?" As it turned out, the child had been sleeping in a tent with his family every night, and waking up at 4:00 in the morning to ride to Newport on the bus with his mother to "go to the doctors" a.k.a. go get another dose of methadone, the drug she was dependent on. Three years later, he is still with his family, homeless, food-less, and blowing welfare money on drugs, just another child to slip through the cracks. Now how could this happen, aren't there programs in place, aren't teachers mandated to report these issues, to file a formal report with the DCF? Yes, but from there the DCF decides, they can choose to investigate a report or simply send a form letter back saying "we have evaluated the case and found it not to be worth investigating." There is simply not enough money, not enough employees, and not enough time to investigate every case. The foster system itself is troubled, one person confided that they stopped fostering children because they were afraid to be alone with them. Some children had been in the system for some time and had learned to look out for themselves. If they were angry with families, or wanted a change, they could simply say they had been hit or abused and bam, they get a new family and the old one gets a black mark. It was because of this happening that the family decided to stop fostering, and they were not alone, the number of foster families is falling and the turnover rate is excessive. My guidance counselor told me stories of foster children at our school who would be found loitering around outside, and when asked why, they would reply, "I dont know who I am going home with tonight."There is hope however, people are still trying; my uncle has been fostering a pair of children, for nigh on ten years now, at first full time, but now working in a partnership with the parents to ge the family back on their feet, but more on that later. (They are on a trip and can't be reached)
Felice, Carrie. "DCF and the Foster System." Personal interview. 2 Oct. 2015.
Grant, Phil. "DCF and the Foster System." Personal interview. 2 Oct. 2015.
********, ****. "Personal Stories About the Foster System." Personal interview. 5 Oct. 2015.
Brown, Jeff. "DCF and the Foster System." Interview by Alexander C. Bickart. 4 Oct. 2015:
Assorted Friends Who Didn't Help Much.
(Word Count Stipulations are Agonizing)
Hi Alex,
ReplyDeleteJust want to start by saying, I find your specific content AND your prose very very engaging. Just curious if this post was a first write-through or did you spent some time crafting it? If the former, I’m impressed (and jealous), and if the latter, I’m still impressed as you took the time to consider your audience!
During this phase of ‘inquiry’ as you continue to gather stories and data that reveal the often invisible issues regarding the welfare of Vermont children and families, please consider the following questions: what would change look like, who are the people who are in a position to effect change, and how might you best achieve action/movement toward change?
As I read your substitute’s story, I was reminded of a book I read about five years ago, called “Half the Sky.” Have you read it or seen the related PBS series? Anyway the book emerged after two journalists stumbled upon what they later identified as 'the' human rights issue of the early 21st Century, namely gender-cide, the overwhelming phenomenon of women dying around the world for just being women. See link below if you are interested in reading excerpt from the Introduction. The reason I bring it up is that as the journalists kept investigating areas of the world where women were dying, they stumbled upon a singular solution: if women participated in the economic growth of the community, they become too ‘valuable’ to kill or let die. So that is my long-winded way of saying keep your eyes and ears out for what possible avenues of change might be offered by your interviews and research that could stay or reverse such an escalating social issue that affects us all.
Also this week, Mr. O’Leary, somewhere, posted a New York Times profile about a homeless girl. I recommend you check it out for two reasons: one, it is a stunning yet simple example of digital story-telling AND the author masterfully weaves, through text and image, the myriad ways that homeless children are invisible or to use your word, hidden.
I look forward to next week’s post . . .
Kate Carroll
PS Regarding word count: I recommend that going forward you submit official/assigned posts within the recommended range, but then consider submitting extra posts for your own planning/development purposes.
PPS Just wondering if you want me
to point out typos, spelling, etc. Sorry I’m an English Teacher, had to ask, but I can also ignore them . . .
Links:
http://www.npr.org/books/titles/162699796/half-the-sky-turning-oppression-into-opportunity-for-women-worldwide#excerpt
http://www.nytimes.com/projects/2013/invisible-child/#/?chapt=0
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHello Alex,
ReplyDeleteBeginning a blog, essay, or idea with a question can be a strong way to draw a reader into the subject matter in which you intend to address. The hook asks, “What makes a social issue even graver than it already is?” This is a splendid and skillful way to begin! You definitely captured my attention!
However, according to the answer stated in the blog, it would be an issue in which “nobody” is aware exists. Here, readers are being led to expect a revelatory announcement. In other words, the audience will be anticipating some sort of surprise concern that escapes the awareness of most people in society. This method of approach is further reinforced by the mention of abortion, gun control, and climate change, which are all controversial and highly recognizable social issues, to differentiate from the one that the author will introduce. The first two-in-the-half sentences prime readers for a real eye-opening disclosure. What one supposes would follow, would be the introduction of an issue in which most of society remains oblivious. Though problems within the foster care system are of serious importance, and a topic that deserves tremendous attention, it is a rather well-known and often examined issue amongst various stakeholders. It is a visited topic of discussion in politics, news channels, and classrooms across the country. This disparity can be easily corrected by simply equated the complications within foster care as a challenge as immensely important as abortion, gun control, and climate change.
Keeping in mind the people who will be able to enact change, how will you convince them that the challenges faced within the foster care system are as critical as the issues of abortion, gun control, and climate change? What will further differentiate your topic from those other issues?
I really enjoy reading your blog posts. Keep it up!
Best,
Carissa
Hi Carissa,
ReplyDeleteJust something I am unclear on, am I supposed to respond to your comment? Being able to openly converse with you and Kate here in the comments section would be a huge help but I am unsure if that is really allowed.
Thanks, Alex
Hi Alex,
ReplyDeleteThere are no restrictions on correspondence within your blog. Converse and ask away . . .
Kate
Hi Alex,
ReplyDeleteJust saw this Letter to the Editor in Middlebury's local paper, The Addison Independent. If the link does not work, I can copy and paste whole article to you in an email:
http://addisonindependent.com/201510opinion-barre-shooting-hits-local-dcf-hard
Hey Kate,
DeleteThat link is not working, but if you would email it to me I would love to read it.